Playbook

    How to Migrate from Mailchimp to Constant Contact

    A practical, step-by-step guide to moving your list, templates, and automations without losing subscribers or sender reputation.

    This is part of the Supercharged Email playbook, built to help you get better results without guesswork.

    TL;DR

    • Export your contacts as a CSV, keep tags, segments, and subscribe dates.
    • Re-authenticate your domain (SPF, DKIM, DMARC) before your first send.
    • Warm the list, start with your most engaged subscribers, not the whole list.
    • Rebuild templates from scratch in Constant Contact's editor rather than importing HTML.
    • Keep both platforms active for 30 days. Cancel Mailchimp only after the first clean send.

    1. Export Your List the Right Way

    • In Mailchimp: Audience → All contacts → Export Audience. You'll get a ZIP with one CSV per audience.
    • Critical columns to keep: email, first name, last name, tags, signup source, signup date, last engagement date.
    • Drop unsubscribed, cleaned, and complained contacts before importing. Bringing them over will tank your sender reputation.
    • Keep a separate file of "engaged in the last 90 days", this is your warm-up list.

    2. Set Up Constant Contact Cleanly

    • Start with a fresh Constant Contact account, sign up free first, set up later.
    • Verify your sending domain before importing anyone. Domain verification protects deliverability.
    • Set up SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records on your domain. Constant Contact provides the exact values.
    • Match your Mailchimp segments to Constant Contact lists or tags. Tags are usually closer to Mailchimp's behaviour.

    3. Import in Two Phases

    • Phase 1 (Day 1): import the "engaged in the last 90 days" list. This is your warm-up audience.
    • Phase 2 (Day 30): import the rest only after you've sent 2-3 successful campaigns to the warm list.
    • Constant Contact will ask you to confirm permission for any contact you import. Answer honestly, false positives bite you later.

    4. Rebuild Templates (Don't Migrate HTML)

    • Mailchimp's HTML rarely renders cleanly in Constant Contact's editor. Rebuild from scratch.
    • Pick 1–2 base templates that match your brand. Variations live as duplicates.
    • Use Constant Contact's mobile preview before saving, most editors render fine on desktop but break on mobile.
    • Need a template starting point? Browse our free template library.

    5. Rebuild Automations

    • Map every Mailchimp automation to a Constant Contact equivalent (welcome series, abandoned cart, post-purchase).
    • Test each automation with a dummy email address before turning it live.
    • Run old and new automations in parallel for one week. Turn off Mailchimp's once Constant Contact has shipped two clean sends.
    • Use our Drip Sequence Planner to map them out before building.

    6. First Send: Warm Up the List

    • First send: 500–1,000 of your most engaged subscribers, not the whole list.
    • Subject line: announce the move. Make it human. "Quick note, you're going to hear from us a bit differently."
    • Watch the open rate. If it's below 20%, something's off (deliverability, list quality, or domain reputation). Pause before sending more.
    • Scale to 25%, 50%, then 100% over the first two weeks.

    7. Cancel Mailchimp Last

    • Keep both platforms active for at least 30 days.
    • Confirm Constant Contact is sending cleanly with normal open/click rates before cancelling.
    • Download a final export of your Mailchimp data before cancelling. Once it's gone, it's gone.
    • Update any signup forms, embedded codes, and integrations pointing at Mailchimp.

    Do this today

    • Export Mailchimp audience as CSV (drop unsubscribed + complained)
    • Sign up for Constant Contact and verify your sending domain
    • Configure SPF, DKIM, and DMARC records
    • Import the engaged 90-day segment first
    • Rebuild your 1–2 most-used templates from scratch
    • Recreate your top automations and test with a dummy address
    • Send your first warm-up campaign to 500 engaged subscribers
    • Wait 30 days and confirm clean sends before cancelling Mailchimp

    Frequently asked

    How long does migration take?+
    Plan for 2–4 weeks end-to-end. The actual import is one afternoon; the warm-up, template rebuild, and parallel-run period is what takes time.
    Will I lose subscribers in the move?+
    Some, yes, anyone who hasn't engaged in 6+ months has a low chance of opening regardless. That's healthy. A clean smaller list outperforms a stale larger one.
    Can I keep my signup forms working?+
    Yes. Embed Constant Contact's form code in place of Mailchimp's, or use a form builder that supports both. Test the submission goes to the right place before swapping.
    What happens to my Mailchimp automations during the transition?+
    Keep them running until Constant Contact's equivalents are fully tested. Turn them off one at a time as the new ones go live. Never run both at the same time for the same contact.
    Why are my open rates lower right after migrating?+
    Almost always sender-reputation related. New sending IP/domain reputation needs to warm up. Inbox providers throttle until they see consistent engagement.
    Is Constant Contact actually better than Mailchimp?+
    It's better for some people, not all. Constant Contact wins on customer support, ease of use for small teams, and built-in event/list-growth tools. Mailchimp wins on tighter ecommerce integrations and a more designer-friendly editor.

    Put these strategies into action

    Start free with Constant Contact
    Opens Constant Contact's free trial, where you'll see our partner name, Synergy.The account is yours and the price is the same. We may earn a commission.

    Get new email tools in your inbox

    Free tools and quick, practical tips for sending better emails. No spam, unsubscribe anytime.